Tri Tip vs Brisket: What’s the Difference?

It’s not always easy to know the difference between tri-tip and brisket!

They’re two very different types of meat.

The biggest difference between tri-tip and brisket?

They are from opposite ends of the cow.

Brisket is taken from the chest of the cow and tri-tip steak is taken from the rear end of the cow.

They have different textures and flavor profiles and should be cooked differently as well.

Below you’ll find out which cut of meat you should be using for your cookout and how to grill it like a pitmaster!

What Is Brisket?

The brisket is the breast of the cow and it carries most of the animal’s weight.

It’s made up of meat, connective tissue, cartilage, and tendons.

It has a fat cap and a high to moderate marbling throughout.

This is why it’s smoked for a long period of time. It takes time for the connective tissue to break down to juicy gelatin.

What Is Tri-Tip?

The tri-tip is cut from the tip of the sirloin primal so it has a lot less fat marbling than a brisket beef.

It’s a triangular-shaped piece of meat. Funnily enough, it’s famous for looking like the state of California.

It is boneless with a rich, beefy flavor and lean texture that looks and cooks like a steak and it does great on the grill and in the smoker.

It’s a lot easier to cook than brisket because it doesn’t have all that cartilage to break down.

Because of its slight marbling though, it still ends up juicy like a brisket.

Where Can You Buy Tri-Tip and Brisket?

Your brisket can most likely be found at the supermarket or your local butcher shops.

However, you might have to do a bit more digging to find a butcher that sources good quality tri-tip.

Generally, tri-tip is harder to find because there is a higher demand than its supply.

The Flavor Differences Between Tri-Tip and Brisket

Because of its slight marbling tri-tip still has a beefy, buttery flavor but isn’t as rich in flavor as a brisket.

Properly smoked brisket has an intense, rich beef flavor with a crispy bark; the sort of texture you can only get from brisket beef!

Brisket’s flavor profile is iconic, but both cuts of meat are buttery, beefy, and juicy when cooked right.

Size Differences Between Brisket and Tri-Tip

The entire weight of brisket is anywhere between 12 to 20 pounds.

Whereas the cut of tri-tip is only three to four pounds.

What Are the Cost Differences Between Tri-Tip and Brisket?

Ironically, brisket is cheaper than tri-tip.

It’s priced at roughly $4 per pound although you will be buying a large chunk of meat so it does add up. Tri-tip is normally double that per pound.

This is because it’s rich in protein and harder to source than brisket.

Which Is Better, Brisket or Tri-Tip?

The tri-tip is high in protein so a lot of gym-goers will eat it for that reason but there really is no better, ultimately.

The answer boils down to how many people you want to feed and what type of barbequing you’re up for.

Are you up for a slow and low smoking experience or a quick and high grill?

The tri-tip does take a quarter of the time to prepare and cook than a brisket.

But a well-cooked brisket, even though it’s a slow cooking process is a real treat if it’s done right.

Plus, a tri-tip won’t feed anywhere as near as many people as a brisket will.

Is One Better for Smoking Than the Other?

Tri-tip is easier to smoke because it has less connective tissue to break down.

But it certainly doesn’t stop people from smoking a brisket.

More people attempt to do a beef brisket because of its familiarity, but also because when you do it right, it turns out unbelievably juicy and tender.

They both do very well in the smoker.

But if brisket isn’t done right it can turn out dry and overly chewy- an overall miserable experience.

Which Meat Is Better to Cook for What Occasion?

Both are sure to impress, especially if smoked to perfection!

But a brisket will serve 12 people comfortable with leftovers for days.

If it’s just a small family dinner tri-tip will do just fine.

If you want to do tri-tip for a large group, grab two to four.

How to Prepare Brisket

You’ll want the brisket to be slightly warm or at room temperature before you put it in the smoker.

This is so your smoker isn’t overworking itself to keep the temperature at the steady heat you want.

Trim any excess fat off the fat cap to minimize steaming in the smoker and leave about 1/4 of fat on the meat.

Simply rub salt and black pepper or your favorite dry herbs and let it sit to marinate for 2-12 hours.

How to Smoke Brisket

Choose your favorite flavor of wood chip and set your smoker to 220°F.

Put your brisket in the smoker, fat facing up, and remove it once the internal temperature hits 204°F.

A good rule of thumb to go by is to cook it on a pound basis.

So, for every pound of meat, you want to have it in the smoker for 1.5-2 hours.

Pull the brisket from the smoker when it reach 204°F.

Before you serve it, wrap it in a towel and let the meat rest for a further 1-2 hours in a cooler.

What Are Some Good Cooking Methods for Tri-Tip?

The most popular way of cooking tri-tip is to smoke it and then grill it.

How to Prepare Tri-Tip

Like the brisket, keep it out of the fridge until it’s at room temperature.

Trim any excess fat, and season with your favorite spices, salt and pepper.

Smoking Tri-Tip

We don’t need to go overboard smoking the tri-tip, so set your smoker to 250°F and let it cook until the internal temperature hits 135°F.

See my comprehensive guide to smoking tri-tip here.

If your using a Pit Boss, I have also got a recipe for tri-tip here.

Both parts of the meat are rich in vitamins, protein, and minerals and both are worth the shot at smoking at least once.

Both have a robust beefy flavor suitable for any occasion.

There are many recipes and seasonings too.

Once you’ve given the basic salt and pepper a go, you can start experimenting with other flavors!

Smoke On!

Charlie

Author: Charlie Reeves
Hi, I’m Charlie, I am head taste tester at Simply Meat Smoking! I love it grilling, smoking, and getting out in the yard with the kids! The family also love to test all my recipes (especially my EXTRA CRISPY pulled pork, smoky pork loin, and ANY SEAFOOD I grill)

You will usually find me playing with the kids, perfecting my brisket bark, or sipping beers with boys around the fire. Can’t wait to share all my delicious smoking and grilling adventures with you!

You can read more on our About Us page.

Hungry For More?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.