March 3, 2018

The Best Electric Smoker Under $200 (Updated July 2018)


Buying a smoker is a big commitment. For the most part it is a big financial commitment. When starting out smoking its hard to go ahead and spend a lot of money on something that you don't really know to much about. Or that you are not to sure you are actually going to make use of.

Each different make and model of a smoker has its own pros and cons. This guide is designed to help those that are new to smoking and are not quite sure what they are looking for just yet. We have compared the best electric smokers under $200 to make sure you make the best decision, and save a little bit of money in the process. 

We hope this guide comes in handy and helps you become the backyard entertainer you have always dreamt of! 

The Best Electric Smoker Under $200 Comparison Table 

Masterbuilt 20073716
Masterbuilt 20071117 30" Digital Electric Smoker
dyna glo electric smoker
old smokey electric smoker

Model

Masterbuilt 20073716

Masterbuilt 20071117

Smoke Hollow 3016DEW

Dyna-Glo DGU505BAE-D

Old Smokey Electric Smoker

Dimensions

15.9 x 23.6 x 23.4 inches

20.4 x 19.8 x 33.2 inches

20.4 x 19.8 x 33.2 inches

23.5 x 18.4 x 35 inches

17.5 x 17.5 x 29 in


Cooking Area

12 sq inches

265 sq inches

540 sq inches

505 sq inches

-

Warranty

90 day Manufacturer Warranty

90 day Manufacturer Warranty

1 Year Manufacturer Warranty

1 Year Manufacturer Warranty

1 Year Manufacturer Warranty

The Best Electric Smoker Under $200 Individual Reviews

  Specifications

  • Height: 15.9 inches
  • Width: 23.6 inches 
  • Depth:  23.4 inches 
  • Weight: 21.6 lbs
  • Cooking Area: 730 sq in

  Key Features

Portable: It's not just a pretty name. The 20073716 Portable Electric Smoker is just that. Amazingly portable. The unit includes a removable water pan and chip tray making it extremely easy to store, transport and maneuver. Even the legs fold up! This makes it a perfect companion for the RV, packing it in the car to take to the campground or even to throw in the car for the kids Saturday sports events.

Lightweight: The total unit weight is just shy of 22 lbs. This is light enough to carry anywhere. For those of you who are adventurous, I highly recommend also buying the Masterbuilt 20080116 Portable Smoker Carrying Bag it makes bringing this bad boy anywhere a real breeze. The bag is super heavy duty and has lots of pockets for storage.

Temperature Control: There are three temperature settings on this smoker. Low, medium and high. You can easily change between these settings with the simple dial. The dial is simply placed on the front door where you can easily keep an eye on the temperature and make changes accordingly.

The Element: Having 1400 watts of heating power, the 20073716 has enough power to smoke a range of foods in just a couple of hours. I found the smoker can hold a constant temperature well, however, because of its smaller size you do need to keep on top of the wood chip levels.

Removable Pans: The removable wood and water pan makes refilling a breeze. Removing the tray can be done while the smoker is running without disturbing the cooking process. Perfect!

Foldable Legs: The feature that I loved the most was the foldable legs. These legs are surprisingly sturdy and very convenient. They can be folded flat under the unit for easy storage anywhere and they have enough height to keep the unit safe from dirt, mud, sand, and grass.

What I Liked

  • check
    Large capacity for a transportable unit
  • check
    Removable water and chip trays
  • check
    Lightweight and very portable
  • check
    One of the easiest units to transport
  • check
    Ready to use right out of the box
  • check
    Easy to clean with the removable internal rack system
  • check
    Lightweight at slightly under 22 pounds

What I Didn't Like

  • Warranty period is short, only ninety days
  • The grease catching system can get clogged

 Verdict

For me, there are no two ways around it. The Masterbuilt 20073716 Portable Electric Smoker is a must have for anyone who likes getting into the great outdoors and cooking. It makes quick and easy work of cooking for friends and family away from the kitchen. You really can’t beat this thing on price, convenience or quality.

4.5 / 5 Stars

  Specifications

  • Height: 33.2 inches
  • Width: 20.4 inches
  • Depth: 19.8 inches
  • Weight: 39.3 lbs
  • Cooking Area: 730 sq inches

  Key Features

Built In Thermometer: The easy to read built in digital thermometer lets you check, set and maintain the smoking environment with ease. I found that the thermometer was accurate throughout the entire cook.

Insulated: The 20071117 is extremely well insulated. Therefore it maintains a constant temperature and still performs really well in cold climates.

Temperature Control: The digital thermometer lets you control the temperature at the click of a button. Easily choose and maintain temperatures between the 100° – 275°F.

Additional add-ons: One really cool thing about the 20071117 is the fact that you can buy the base model and add on any additional extras that you would lie. This is really great because it keeps the cost down and you can customize the smoker to suit your own needs. For example, I don’t think that you need to have a smoker that includes a window. The window is great for the first 15 minutes of the cook, however, then it just gets smoky and dirty and you can’t see anything anyway.

Smoking Racks: Inside the smoker are four chrome coated smoking racks. These racks are sturdy and well spaced giving you lots of space for a selection of meats.

The Size: The 30 inch model gives the average smoker more than enough room. The large 730 sq inches of cooking space will be enough to feed a small army of backyard feasters.

Patented side wood chip loading system: Easily add wood chips without opening the smoker door, keeping all the heat in the smoker.

What I Liked

  • check
    The Large cook space
  • check
    The endless options for customization
  • check
    Convenient and easy to use side wood loading system
  • check
    The quality for the price
  • check
    Easy to use temperature gauge

What I Didn't Like

  • The unit is a little heavier than other making it hard to move around

Verdict

The Masterbuilt 20071117 30 inch is a great smoker for those who are after a quality smoker at an affordable price. The base model is a good model for those who don’t want to spend a tonne of money but are after a quality unit that you can build on in the future. It is also large enough to handle feeding a decent size crowd, perfect for backyard entertaining and feeding an impromptu party. 

4 / 5 Stars

  Specifications

  • Height: 41.5 inches
  • Width: 20.6 inches
  • Depth: 22.3 inches
  • Weight: 51 lbs
  • Cooking Area: 540 sq in

  Key Features

Large External Wood Tray: The new external wood chip tray is super easy to use and lets you add more wood chips without opening the smoker and disturbing the smoking environment.

Cooking Grids: The three chrome plated cooking grids are fully adjustable to fit almost any cut of meat.

Viewing Window: On some smokers, the viewing window gets messy fast, not this one it managed to stay clean for most of the cook. However, when it does get grubby it is a breeze to clean.

The Heat Source: The massive 1500 watt electric heat source has plenty of power to cook everything from meat to cheese in as little as a couple of hours.

Digital Controller: The new digital electronic controls led display is super easy and use and even easier to see. Easily change the temperature and cook time with the press of a button.

Strudy Construction: Everything from the legs to the handles on this bad boy are made with durability in mind. This smoker is built to last. Everything from the handles to the wheels.


What I Liked

  • check
    Viewing window which is surprisingly easy to clean
  • check
    Impressive 1500 watt heat source
    The easy to use external wood chip tray
  • check
    Three chrome plated cooking grids
  • check
    Large cooking capacity compared to others in this price range

What I Didn't Like

  • The unit sometimes has trouble with drainage. The main cavity does get left with fat from time to time.

Verdict

In my opinion, the new Smoke Hollow 30 inch is a really durable smoker that is truly made for year round smoking. It is also well insulated so you know that you can smoke in the middle of winter without compromising temperature. The easy to use new digital controller and wood chip tray are great additions and help create a very user friendly experience. This smoker is just waiting to impress your guests at any time of the year!

4 / 5 Stars

  Specifications

  • Height: 35.9 inches
  • Width: 23.5 inches
  • Depth: 18.4 inches
  • Weight: 46.3 lbs
  • Cooking Area: 505 sq in

  Key Features

The Burner: The powerful 1,650-Watt burner ensures that no matter what the temperature is outside or what meat you are planning on cooking.

Adjustable Racks: The 3 adjustable and removable chrome-plated cooking grates are sturdy and the runners slide easily.|

Wood Chip Loader: The conveniently placed side access wood chip loader reduces heat and smoke loss when more wood chips are needed.

Temperature Dial: The manual temperature dial allows for fine-tuning to get your perfect cooking temperature.

Temperature Guage: Easily read stainless steel temperature gauge with handy "Smoke Zone" feature which indicates the perfect temperature for infusing flavor.

Insulation: The double-walled firebox retains heat really well. I didn't notice any fluctuations in temperature throughout the cooking process.

What I Liked

  • check
    Well insulated 
  • check
    Powerful burner that regulates a steady cooking temperature in all conditions 
  • check
    The handy 'Smoke Zone' Feature  
  • check
    The side entry wood chip loader
  • check
    The general sturdy construction of the unit, carry handles and legs

What I Didn't Like

  • The catch can does not catch all the drippings and around 1/3 ended up on the floor and dripping down the unit

Verdict

The Dyna-Glo is a fantastic little smoker for those who are looking for a cheap, quick and easy alternative to some of the more expensive and hard to use charcoal or wood smokers.

It basically comes ready to use out of the packet and is a real joy to use. The removable trays give you plenty of options for cooking different meat cuts.

You get a surprisingly authentic flavor out of this unit in a short time, quite impressive compared to the cheap price.

The overall construction is great and it is a sturdy little unit perfect for any beginner or professional looking to save a little bit of money.

4 / 5 Stars

  Specifications

  • Height: 29 inches
  • Width: 15.5 inches
  • Depth: 15.5 inches
  • Weight: 23 lbs

  Key Features

Heat Thermostat: An advanced heat thermostat is added to the smoker to help you regulate and execute a variety of cooking time settings and styles. Once you set the temperature on this kit, you no longer have to worry about the heating. This kit will digitally control the inside temperature of the grill using its advanced sensors and heat regulator. 

Simplicity: 
The Old Smokey Electric Smoker greatest feature is the simplicity. We think it is perfect for anyone starting out or the advanced cook who just likes to work with the best yet simple product. There is no need to worry about parts failing or display malfunctions, sudden electronic fails, and so on. Although it’s simple, it smokes and cooks exceptional good meat.

Tightly Fitting Lid: 
One of the most important features of a smoker is the seals and tightly fitting lid. If your smoker isn’t sealing then you are losing precious heat or smoke. This unit seals tight which means it also it creates the condensation, this then falls back on the meat, keeping it juicy and the enhancing flavor even more.We also found that with no leaks it made cleaning the smoker much easier. You don’t have grease dripping don’t the sides to scrub off later making the cleaning much easier.

Portability: 
The Old Smokey is one of the easy smokers to move. It only weighs about 25 pounds, and it features two side handles. So, you have to worry about having a friend handy to move it. You can do it by yourself with almost no effort at all. This makes it a great option to take camping, tailgating or just around to a neighbor's places.

Strong sturdy fireproof handles: 
The safety of this unit is top notch. The handles are made of with heat-resistant materials. No matter how long you cook, you can always lift the lid holding the handles safely.

Easy inserting or removing Grills:
The grills of this unit were extremely easy to rearrange. It has two grills, upper and lower, with diameters of 14.5” and 12.5” respectively. Each of these has handles to make inserting and removing them an easier task.

What I Liked

  • check
    Handy and convenient to use
  • check
    Simple Startup. All you need to do is plug in the smoker/grill and start using it!
  • check
    Even heat distribution
  • check
    Large cooking space with a 15” inch diameter and two grills
  • check
    Super portable, so use It anywhere you want. It is only 25 pounds!

What I Didn't Like

  • Can get very hot while in use 

Verdict

Overall, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker is a high quality product worth buying if you're after something simple yet durable. Those looking to make succulent, the juicy smoked meat will get the most of their money with this. One of our favorite features was the ease of assembly. You can literally pull it out the box, wrap and start using it.There are many smokers that claim to be the best, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker always does what it promises- quality smoking and grilling with ease and convenience.

You’ll become a master of cooking after two or three times of using this smoker.

4 / 5 Stars

Rate this post

Charlie

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply:

>